What role can schools play in developing young people’s social agency?
Over the past few weeks 40 Year 4 pupils have come together for a series of RSA4 workshops that have centred on developing character traits and soft skills to deliver positive social change through youth social action.
It seems only fitting that in the same timeframe we’ve seen the recent Schools Strike 4 Climate movement inspire hundreds of thousands of pupils across 100 countries to walk out of school in protest. As well as drawing attention to the issue at hand, this action has also ignited powerful discussions about the role education plays in fostering young people’s civic engagement.
In his Guardian article, ‘If children don’t join the climate strike, their schools are underachieving’, David Reed, Director of Generation Change, has gone as far as to say those schools have failed to empower their pupils with the skills and knowledge to join the protests. As a result, they have deprived their pupils of a learning opportunity no classroom can teach.
Politicians and school leaders have been left grappling with the argument should we condone, condemn or even celebrate this particular expression of youth agency?
An education with character?
When we talk about developing pupil’s civic engagement we tend to frame it in the broader context of character education – that learning both formally and informally can support young people to develop positive character traits or virtues – within schools.
The idea that pupils need a broad education, one that nurtures specific positive character traits and virtues is not new. Since 2012, character education has been heralded within education policy as the silver bullet for developing well-rounded young people who are better prepared to contribute to society. This drive for a character focused education followed in the wake of the 2011 summer riots across Britain. It’s encouraging that in 2019 we are discussing character education in relations to a much more positive mobilisation of youth.
Yet much can be said on the argument that our current education system can be characterised by accountability to performance targets and an ‘education by numbers’, designed solely for the task of getting pupils through exams.
Academic success and securing the qualifications that will open doors for every pupil is important. However, academic attainment forms just one aspect of supporting young people to flourish. We need pupils who are resilient to life’s challenges and can bounce back after disappointment. We want our young people to be ambitious about what they can achieve, set goals for themselves and work towards them with determination.
No aspect of what is outlined above is exclusive to formal learning alone, and neither should it be.
Last month, Education Secretary Damian Hinds reconfirmed the Department for Education’s commitment to character education. During his keynote address to the Church of England’s Educational Leadership conference, Hinds announced youth social action – practical action in the service of others to create positive change – as one of five core foundations for building character.
‘I have heard repeatedly from teachers, parents and young people themselves about the areas of activity which will help develop character and resilience. All of them combine elements that will stretch and challenge and will help young people think, develop and grow and which will enhance their self-esteem and confidence.’
Dual relationship and double benefit
The joint statement from the Jubilee Centre for Character and Virtues and Step up to Serve iwill campaign highlights that youth social action fundamentally contributes to the development and expression of character. The connection between character development and social action is a dual relationship in which one fosters the other.
‘character development – and the importance of virtue – should be viewed as a core element of social action, empowering all young people to develop a clearer sense of their relationships with others, as well as of their own purpose in life’.
The Jubilee Centre has suggested that there is a set of building blocks to character that centre on four types of virtues; intellectual, moral, civic and performance.
Intellectual virtues, such as critical thinking and autonomy, are central to equipping young people to make informed decisions about the world around them. In addition, young people need to have moral virtues that act as their social compass to guide this decision making and include, among others, compassion, sense of justice and integrity. Civic virtues are the traits that enable us to feel a strong sense of belonging to our communities and enable us to act as responsible citizens. Finally, performance virtues are often used to refer to soft skills such as confidence, resilience and teamwork that enable young people to act on intellectual, moral and civic virtues.
Developing a strong sense of these virtues in young people should develop a commitment among the next generation to tackling social issues and practical action for change. Evidence has shown that the positive impact of participating in youth-led social action has a ‘double benefit’ for the young people involved, and the communities the action serves. Social action develops a range of building block virtues in young people through the learning process of designing and delivery the action, as well as empowering communities.
It’s this double benefit that offers young people the opportunity to develop skills that employers increasingly say they need more of from the workforce of the future. A report published by CIPD and Step-up to Serve’s iwill campaign found that 67% of employers felt candidates who have social action experience demonstrate more employability skills such as teamwork, communication and understanding of their local community.
Social action as a means of developing and expressing character might just be the antidote to the ‘education by numbers’ system, and the answer to the question how can schools produce the well-rounded young citizens we need?
Tackling more than just climate change
The Strike for Climate Change movement has the potential to challenge society’s perception of young people’s civic engagement. The RSA report ‘Teenagency: how young people can create a better world’, shows young people’s participation in social action significantly outweighs adults perception. Just 5% of adults think that young people today are likely to contribute towards social action compared to the actual 68% of young people have participated in volunteering, fundraising or some form of social action.
However, challenging perceptions is about more than just adults preconceived ideas. While 84% of young people want to help others, only 52% believe that they can make a positive difference in their communities. Often young people consider their age, position in society and inexperience to be limiting factors. However, evidence shows that building character traits and virtues such as confidence in their ability to make a difference encourages greater participation among young people, especially those from disadvantaged backgrounds.
We know that schools are a particularly ripe environment for developing these character traits through social action as 74% of those aged 10 – 20 year olds who have participated in social action got involved through their school. Yet a Teacher Voice Omnibus survey carried out the NFER for the iwill campaign shows only a third of teacher’s surveys felt social action was embedded within their school culture. This gap between value and opportunity is particularly pronounced at the primary level with the majority for primary school teachers indicating that either they don’t know what social action is or have not thought about implementing it in their school.
Schools need to be given more space to develop opportunities for character-based learning to be ‘taught, caught and sought’ – and social action is a powerful mechanism for delivering this.
I’m hopeful that the announcement that Schools Strike 4 Climate initiator Greta Thunberg – at 16 years old – has been nominated for the Noble Peace Prize demonstrates the influence young people can have, particularly when social action and education meet. What started as a one-person protest has kick-started a global youth movement.
If Greta does go on to receive the Noble Peace Prize in October she will be the youngest ever recipient. This is where the RSA4 project draws on recent research that signals Year 4 as a critical stage for introducing young people to youth social action. Research from the Jubilee Centre finds that those who start volunteering before the age of ten are more than twice as likely to form a ‘habit of service’ (a commitment to continuing to volunteer) than if they start at 16-18 years of age. It is not surprising then that Greta first took an interest in tackling climate change when she was just 8 years old.
Regardless of where you sit on the controversy surrounding students striking during school time, you cannot deny the next generation have a strong desire (and need) to be activists for positive social change in times of great uncertainty.
More importantly, they are ready to act. As educators, we need to give them the opportunity, character and know-how to lead it.
With thanks to Pears #iwill Fund, the RSA and RSA Academies will be working together for the next two years to investigate what meaningful social action looks like at primary school level through the RSA4 project.
- The #iwill Fund is made possible thanks to £40 million joint investment from The National Lottery Community Fund and the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) to support young people to access high-quality social action opportunities.
- The #iwill Fund brings together a group of organisations who all contribute funding to embed meaningful social action into the lives of young people.
- Social action involves activities such as campaigning, fundraising and volunteering, all of which enable young people to make a positive difference in their communities as well as develop their own skills and knowledge.
- The #iwill Fund supports the aims of the #iwill campaign – to make involvement in social action a part of life for young people, by recognising the benefit for both young people and their communities.